top of page

Oil Paintings vs. Prints: Which One Belongs in Your Collection?

Writer: Mary Katherine FickelMary Katherine Fickel

"Buying an original painting is like dating someone who actually listens—prints are just the ‘copy-paste’ version." MK Fickel-Owner/Curator The Good Art Co.


If you’re venturing into the world of fine art collecting, you’ve probably stumbled upon the great debate: original oil paintings vs. prints. Which one should you invest in? Which will add real value to your collection? And most importantly, which one will make your walls look like you actually know what you’re doing?

We’re here to break it all down—the good, the bad, and the aesthetically questionable.

 

The Case for Original Oil Paintings:

The Real Deal & The Soul Factor: Because Texture Matters.

You know that feeling when you stand in front of an original painting and can almost sense the artist's presence? That’s the magic of an oil painting. The texture, the depth, the brushstrokes that capture every flick of emotion—these are things no print can replicate.


 

Original oil paintings aren’t just art; they’re experiences.

A high-quality oil painting catches light differently at various angles, giving it an evolving quality. Prints? Well, they catch dust.

White living room with modern decor and a large abstract in blues from the good art company hanging on the wall
So, what will it be? The real deal or the copy-paste version? Choose wisely—your walls (and future art legacy) are counting on you.
  • Investment Potential: Art That Pays Off

Let’s talk numbers. Oil painting investment isn’t just for the ultra-rich—it’s for anyone who understands that art, unlike your ex, appreciates over time.

An original work by an emerging artist can increase in value dramatically, especially if they gain recognition. Even lesser-known but skilled artists create pieces that hold or increase in worth. Compare that to a print, which depreciates faster than a new car driving off the lot.

Collectors don’t just buy art; they buy stories, authenticity, and rarity—all of which oil paintings deliver.


 

One of a Kind: Exclusivity Has Power: Owning an original means you have the only one in existence. You and the artist share a unique connection. Meanwhile, prints are like fast food—mass-produced, easy to access, and everyone has one.


 


Kitchen with pastry and coffee grinder on wood counter with a peach still life painting hanging above from the good art company
If you’re just looking to fill a blank wall with something nice, prints will do the job (but you won’t impress any serious collectors at dinner parties).
The Case for Prints: The Budget-Friendly Alternative. Alright, we get it. Not everyone is ready to shell out thousands for an oil painting. This is where prints come in.
  • Affordability: Art for the People

Fine art prints allow more people to enjoy artwork without needing a trust fund. A high-quality, limited-edition print can be an excellent way to start collecting without breaking the bank.

If you’re decorating on a budget or just dipping your toes into the art world, prints let you enjoy the aesthetics without the financial commitment of an original.


  • Accessibility: Your Favorite Art, Anytime

Some masterpieces are simply not for sale (or they cost more than your house). Prints let you own reproductions of iconic works, making art more accessible.

A print of a Van Gogh might not have the thick, expressive brushstrokes of the original, but it’s still Van Gogh gracing your living room. And that’s better than bare walls.


  • Decor Flexibility: Swap It Out Like Fast Fashion

If you like to refresh your space frequently, prints are a low-risk way to do it. With original oil paintings, you’re making a commitment—like a marriage. With prints, you’re just casually dating art.


This flexibility makes prints ideal for trendy decorators or anyone who changes their aesthetic with the seasons.


White living room with hardwood floors with a bright pink and green floral painting by the good art company hangin on the wall
Original oil paintings aren’t just art; they’re experiences.

So, Which One Belongs in Your Collection? The truth?

Both have their place, but it depends on your goals.


If you want an appreciating asset, go for an original oil painting.

If you’re curating a collection of museum-worthy works, nothing beats one-of-a-kind art.

If you love an artist’s work but can’t afford an original, a high-quality, limited-edition print can be the next best thing.


If you’re just looking to fill a blank wall with something nice, prints will do the job (but you won’t impress any serious collectors at dinner parties).


Final Verdict: Invest Smart, Buy What You LoveAt the end of the day, the best art to collect is the one that speaks to you. If an original oil painting calls your name and you can afford it—buy it. If a print of your favorite masterpiece makes you happy, that’s worth something too.


 

But remember, art isn’t just decoration, it’s a statement. And nothing makes a bigger statement than an original painting.


So, what will it be? The real deal or the copy-paste version? Choose wisely—your walls (and future art legacy) are counting on you.


Are you looking to start or grow your art collection but unsure where to begin? Our

Free digital Guide to Collecting Art is your ultimate resource! Packed with expert insights, practical tips, and must-know strategies, this guide will help you navigate the art world with confidence—whether you're a first-time buyer or a seasoned collector. Discover how to find artwork that resonates with you, invest wisely, and build a collection that stands the test of time.

Download your free guide today and start your journey toward owning meaningful, investment-worthy art. Plus, explore our carefully curated selection of original artwork on The Good Art Company—where you'll find stunning pieces by talented artists, perfect for your home, office, or collection. Don't miss out—shop art now and bring beauty into your space!


Front cover of the Art collector guide written by MK Fickel for the Good Art Company

 

Thank you for reading " Oil Paintings vs. Prints: Which One Belongs in Your Collection? ". To keep up with our latest art additions and all our artist's works follow us on Instagram, Pinterest, and YouTube. And visit our Online Art Shop daily for new available artwork.


Oil Paintings vs. Prints: Which One Belongs in Your Collection?

 
 
bottom of page